• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Get Healthy Clean and Lean

Improve your health one day... one step... one bite at a time!

  • Home
  • Get Healthy
  • Get Clean
  • Get Lean
  • About GHCL

Are Protein Shakes And Meal Replacement Shakes The Same Thing?

By GHCL

are-protein-shakes-and-meal-replacement-shakes-the-same-thing

A lot of people tend to use the terms, protein shake (powder) synonymously with meal replacement shake (powder), thinking they are one in the same.

But they’re actually not.

What’s the Difference Between Protein Shakes and Meal Replacement Shakes?

Protein Shakes:

These are typically made with protein powder.  Protein powder is comprised mainly of protein in some form or another, be it whey, soy, whey isolate, brown rice, or pea.  Some are combinations of two or more of the aforementioned protein sources.

They may have some trace vitamins added in, but for the most part, they are straight protein and NOT a complete meal. You would have to actually add the protein powder to other items (carbs and fat) in order to make it more of a complete meal.

Some people achieve this by blending it into their smoothie made with fruit, nuts (or nut butter), greens (or green powder), etc.

Generally, a protein shake can be something whipped up really fast by adding the powder to water, juice, or milk and drinking it before or after a workout.  But it cannot replace an actual meal because, again, it’s just protein.  You could drink it alongside healthy carbs and fat, for instance, some oatmeal with butter or coconut oil added in (carbs and fat).

Meal Replacement Shakes:

An actual meal replacement shake IS a full meal because it has protein, carbs, AND fat.

And like protein shakes, the protein source of meal replacement shakes can vary as well.  The protein content may be higher in protein shakes than in meal replacement shakes, but if you get a good one, it will have adequate protein to fulfill your daily requirement.

BY THE WAY: Do You Think You Know ALL The Benefits of Drinking Meal Replacement Shakes?  Think Again!   Read more…

Meal replacement shakes can also be mixed with water, juice, or milk – although the one I drink is already dairy-free by design so, why add milk to it? lol

You can use add-ins such as fruit or nut butters; but you don’t necessarily HAVE to add anything (unless you just want to for preference) and you will still be quite satiated, as they typically keep you full longer because they are an actual meal.

So hopefully you now have a more clear understanding as to why protein shakes and meal replacement shakes are NOT the same, and you can make the best choice as to what to drink for your particular needs!

Speaking of meal replacement shakes…

If you’re interested in learning about a high-protein meal replacement shake that tastes great, keeps you full for 3-4 hours, and is based on one of THE healthiest ‘diets’ in the world, click here!


More Shake-Based Resources For You:

Can Protein Shakes Make You Sick And If So, Why?

How To Use Meal Replacement Shakes For Weight Loss

Meal Replacement Shakes: Think You Know All The Benefits? Think Again!

Filed Under: Get Healthy, Get Lean, Q & A Tagged With: are protein shakes and meal replacement shakes the same, difference between protein shake and meal replacement shake, protein shake vs meal replacement shake

Hey, how ya doin'? I'm Cherie - wife, mama of 4 and author of this blog post (thanks for checking it out, btw) Listen... I know eating right, losing weight & getting your health together is hard enough without all the conflicting, confusing, "my way or the high way" B.S. information out there, right? Well don't worry, GHCL is here to help you get on the path to better health WITHOUT making it weird.

One day... one step... one BITE at a time, baby!

Primary Sidebar

Improve your health one day, one step, one bite at a time…

How to Make Boxed Pancake Mix Healthier With 2 Simple Additions

How to Eat Vegetables When You Hate Them

Clean Up Your Pantry: Changing Out Refined White Products

Copyright © 2025 · Get Healthy Clean And Lean· All rights reserved.